(312) 202-9000 Appointment

Beyond Saline vs Silicone: Choosing the Most Natural Feeling Implant

Wave Swoosh
breast augmentation patient model at the beach wearing a black bikini and sun hat

Posted on May 18 2024

When choosing a breast implant for breast enlargement, a comparison between saline and silicone implants is essential. Each type offers distinct advantages and disadvantages, and understanding these can help in making an informed decision that aligns with personal preferences and goals. If you're exploring options and wondering how to discern the most natural-feeling implant, this article delves into the advanced materials and technologies that can make a significant difference. We'll examine the latest developments, such as composite and gummy bear implants, the nuanced interplay of implant texture and shape, and the surgeon's tailored approach, all aimed at achieving that sought-after natural softness and movement.

Key Takeaways

  • The evolution of breast implant materials has led to more natural-feeling options, such as advanced silicone gels and composite implants utilizing the patient's own fat.
  • The texture and shape of breast implants, along with personalized surgical techniques, are crucial in achieving a natural look and feel, with options such as smooth, textured, round, and anatomical shapes, as well as distinct gummy bear implants.
  • Long-term considerations, including durability, the risk of capsular contracture, and changes in breast tissue, impact the sustained natural feel of breast implants, requiring ongoing monitoring and potential maintenance.

Understanding Implant Materials: Beyond Saline and Silicone

The discussion around silicone and saline implants frequently revolves around the choice between these two options. Each kind has a similar exterior made of a silicone shell. They differ substantially in terms of what is inside and how they feel to the touch. Implants filled with silicone gel are celebrated for their likeness to natural breast tissue because they provide softness and elasticity that closely mimic that of an actual breast.

To understand more fully, we must explore the development of these substances and their role in achieving an appearance closest to that of natural breasts.

The Evolution of Silicone Gel

Revolutionary advancements in the field of silicone have led to the creation of silicone breast implants that possess increased cross-linking, resulting in a more solid gel capable of maintaining its shape far better than earlier versions. These contemporary silicone gel implants are favored for their soft, spherical appearance and texture closely resembling that of natural breast tissue. These silicone implants are recognized not only for their tactile qualities but also for having reduced risks when it comes to complications, thereby establishing themselves as a strong option for breast implants.

Saline's Role in Natural Outcomes

We should also consider the merits of saline breast implants. These implants are filled with a sterile salt water solution and provide an exceptional benefit in terms of being adjustable. The volume of saline can be precisely calibrated to replicate the natural form and feel of a breast.

If these implants are appropriately filled, they can match the sensation provided by silicone implants. If overfilled, they present an opportunity for achieving a more pronounced and firmer look.

Assessing Implant Textures and Shapes

The surface and contour of breast implants are critical in mimicking the natural bounce and suppleness one desires. While textured implants adhere to the surrounding tissue, their smooth counterparts permit a more fluid motion within the pocket of the breast. The outcome is also significantly affected by whether an implant is shaped spherically or customized anatomically, greatly altering how natural the breasts appear.

Examining these features reveals their importance in either enhancing or diminishing that sought-after natural look.

The Significance of Implant Texture

The surface characteristics of an implant play a crucial role, as they influence how the implant interacts with the adjacent natural breast tissue. Smooth implants possess glossy exteriors and are known for their mobility within the breast cavity, thus simulating a more natural movement similar to that of actual breast tissue.

On the flip side, textured implants tend to stay anchored in place and feel stiffer upon palpation due to their adherence properties. Despite these potential issues, such as noticeable wrinkling or rippling, particularly in individuals with scant natural breast coverage, these textured varieties do offer advantages like diminished chances of capsular contracture and maintaining a constant appearance due to their steadfast positioning.

Round vs. Anatomical Implants

The choice between round and anatomical implants can be likened to deciding whether to wear a timeless ball gown or a custom-fitted suit, each appropriate for different settings. Teardrop-shaped or anatomical implants are praised for their capacity to replicate the natural gradient of an actual breast, creating a shape that extends fluidly from the chest wall. Though they tend to be stiffer, these implants can still provide fullness in the upper pole if skillfully handled by an experienced surgeon.

In contrast, round implants are preferred by those desiring noticeably lifted contours and ample cleavage - they deliver consistent volume throughout, which is sure to draw attention from afar. Nevertheless, this type of glamor does not come without potential complications. There's a heightened chance with round implants that issues like rotation or "bottoming out" may occur.

Gummy Bear Implants: A Unique Option

Gummy bear implants distinguish themselves in the realm of implant options with a resilience reminiscent of their candy counterpart. Crafted from silicone, these robust implants emulate the natural breast with remarkable precision. Designed to align with the body's contours, they possess an anatomical shape that is fuller at the bottom and narrows towards the top. Gummy bear implants are renowned for maintaining their form unwaveringly, even when faced with shell breaches or damage.

Personalization of Breast Augmentation

Breast augmentation is a highly individualized procedure that requires a customized strategy. The key to achieving an enhancement that not only appears but also feels natural lies in the thoughtful selection of implant size, its positioning, and the surgical skill brought into play. Careful consideration of these elements during breast augmentation surgery ensures the fulfillment of the desired outcome.

Combining different techniques, deciding whether to position implants above or below breast tissue, and utilizing the surgeon's artistic ability are all critical aspects in crafting results that complement your unique physique.

Tailoring Implant Size to Body Type

Selecting the appropriate breast implant size is a complex process, which requires careful consideration of various physical factors such as the patient's overall build, height, weight and specific dimensions of their breast tissue. It resembles the intricate task of finding that ideal pair of jeans. It's essential to match the chest wall's base width precisely with that of the implant to achieve an aesthetically pleasing result that appears both natural and well-fitting.

The degree to which an implant projects from the chest also plays a pivotal role in determining how full or perky breasts will appear post-surgery. This aspect must be tailored thoughtfully so as not to disrupt but complement one's inherent body proportions. Ultimately, this meticulous approach aims at sculpting a figure where equilibrium and aesthetic appeal coexist harmoniously.

Placement Techniques for Authenticity

Choosing the optimal location for implant placement, either securely under the muscle or directly beneath the breast tissue, can significantly influence the final outcome. Insertion below the muscular layer is commonly preferred by individuals seeking inconspicuous augmentation, as it furnishes an extra veil of concealment for the implant and consequently yields a more natural breast shape.

The Surgeon's Artistry

Breast augmentation is centered around the surgeon's expertise in skillfully realizing a patient's aspirations with accuracy and understanding. At places such as the Michael Horn Plastic Surgery, surgeons possess a keen insight into crafting enhancements that seem natural and tailor-fit to an individual's body shape and way of life, meeting each patient's unique wishes.

It is through cooperative involvement in the decision-making process that patients play an active role, leading to results that deeply reflect their personal preferences. This shared approach helps foster greater satisfaction and adherence post-procedure.

Psychological Aspects of Implant Choice

Choosing the right breast implant is as much a psychological journey as it is a physical transformation. Emotional concerns may surface, particularly with associations between certain implants and health conditions like breast implant-associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma, squamous cell carcinoma, or breast cancer. The phenomenon of "breast implant illness," with symptoms such as fatigue and joint pain, although not conclusively linked to implants, adds another layer of consideration for prospective patients.

All these factors play into the intricate dance of aligning one's aesthetic goals with the most suitable implant type.

Aligning Expectations with Reality

Embarking on the journey of breast augmentation requires a balance between emotional enthusiasm and realistic expectations. During consultations, an open exchange is fostered, enabling patients to share their aspirations for their breasts, often supported by visual aids. Yet they are advised that individual physical characteristics will dictate distinct results. Advanced tools like 3D imaging are instrumental in helping patients visualize what's achievable on their own bodies.

In this process, the skill and knowledge of the surgeon prove indispensable as they steer patients toward options that embody proportion and aesthetic harmony.

The Importance of Patient Education

Educating patients serves as a guiding light toward achieving a fulfilling experience with their breast surgery. By providing them with the necessary understanding, they are empowered to make decisions that align with their individual aspirations. Tools and software designed for education simplify the complexities of breast procedures, ensuring that patients can explore their choices with assurance and clear insight.

The Impact of Breast Surgery on Self-Image

Undergoing breast augmentation can significantly reshape not only one's physical contour but also one's self-view. This procedure is often a catalyst for bolstering self-esteem in individuals battling with issues related to body image, leading to improved life satisfaction and a harmonious match between personal identity and outward look.

It's essential to approach such surgery cognizant of the fact that changes in appearance might not directly translate into emotional contentment. The post-operative emotional landscape may be complex. It requires patience and sometimes additional support while adjusting to an updated perception of one's own body.

Long-Term Considerations for Natural Feel

Contemplating the enduring experience with breast implants demands thoughtful evaluation of variables that affect their natural sensation and performance as time passes. It's crucial to grasp the concept that breast implants are not intended for lifetime permanence but instead serve as temporary enhancements during a particular phase of life. We should explore what determines the lasting quality of this natural feel and examine ways to preserve it.

Durability of Implant Materials

The longevity of an implant is key to preserving a natural appearance and texture over time. In the past, silicone breast implants faced issues with shell rupture and leakage. Recent advancements have led to the approval by the FDA of new types of silicone gel-filled implants that not only emulate a more natural aesthetic but also offer improved long-lasting durability.

Specifically, gummy bear implants stand out for their resistance to wrinkles and folding, thus maintaining their natural feel longer. Nevertheless, it's important to acknowledge that despite advances in implant technology, there remains a possibility that they may need replacement due to complications down the line, underlining the importance of durability when choosing an implant.

Risks of Capsular Contracture

Even with the highest-quality materials, breast implants may still face complications like capsular contracture. This occurs when the body creates a thick layer of scar tissue around the implant in an effort to protect itself, resulting in increased firmness and possible distortion that detracts from their natural softness and feel.

Certain types of implants - specifically textured ones and those known as "gummy bear" implants - tend to have lower rates of capsular contracture. Placing them under the muscle (submuscular placement) might diminish this risk. For serious cases classified as Grades III or IV by the Baker scale severity measure, surgery could be needed to correct these issues and regain a natural look and sensation in the breast area.

Monitoring Changes in Breast Tissue

As time progresses, the body undergoes transformations that may impact the original outcomes of breast augmentation. It is essential for patients to have regular evaluations with a medical expert to track these changes and confirm that their implants retain an appearance and sensation that mimics natural breasts. Vigilance post-breast implant surgery is imperative, and adherence to FDA-recommended imaging procedures aids in assessing the status of the implants well after they've been placed.

The continuous fine-tuning of implants interacts with the body's innate recuperation mechanisms, influencing patients' perceptions regarding both size and contentment with their enhanced breasts as time elapses.

Navigating Complications and Maintenance

Breast augmentation is a rewarding process, yet it carries the possibility of various challenges and demands continual upkeep. As soon as the implants are in place, their durability begins to diminish over time. They could eventually need replacement due to issues like rupturing or the development of scar tissue among other unforeseen complications.

It's crucial for those who undergo this procedure to be well-informed about how to manage such situations when they occur and acknowledge that diligent aftercare coupled with regular evaluations play a vital role in maintaining both the natural sensation and structural soundness of breast implants.

Dealing with Ruptured Silicone Implant

The "silent rupture" of silicone gel-filled breast implants requires careful attention, as it can be difficult to detect without the help of imaging techniques. In such cases where the implant ruptures, there is a potential for changes in the shape of the breast and discomfort due to the migration of silicone outside the surrounding scar tissue capsule. To identify these silent ruptures, regular monitoring with ultrasound or MRI scans is advised so that if an issue arises, surgical intervention can be planned to remove both the compromised implant and any affected scar tissue.

Addressing Scar Tissue and Implant Tightness

The development of excessive scar tissue can impact the natural softness and movement of breast implants. Ensuring expert surgical procedures are performed along with attentive care after surgery is critical in preventing implant tightness associated with this condition. Techniques such as consistent massages of the breasts, choosing suitable implants for the individual's body, and using medications to decrease inflammation when necessary, can aid in controlling and averting troublesome scar tissue formation.

In instances where scar tissue does pose a problem, there are multiple strategies that may be utilized to regain the preferred movement and softness of the breast. These methods include but are not limited to operative removal or nonoperative approaches like administering steroid injections.


The process of breast augmentation requires a meticulous blend of medical knowledge and aesthetic sensibility, encompassing everything from the choice of implant material to the intricacies of shape and texture. It demands an individualized surgical approach as well as ongoing attention post-operation. Through thoughtful deliberation and guidance from adept breast implant specialists, you can reach a result that not only appears natural but also resonates with your sense of self.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are silicone implants or saline implants more natural-feeling?

To sum up, silicone implants are often perceived as closer to the feel of natural breast tissue because they contain a filling made from silicone gel.

On the other hand, when saline implants are filled and appropriately tuned after surgery, they too can achieve a sensation similar to that of a natural breast.

What is the risk of capsular contracture with breast implants?

The condition known as capsular contracture can cause the tissue surrounding breast implants to harden, which may adversely affect the breasts' natural softness and feel.

Opting for gummy bear implants with a textured surface, to placing them beneath the muscle (submuscular placement), could reduce the likelihood of this risk.

Can breast implants rupture, and what happens if they do?

Indeed, breast implants are prone to rupturing. Should a saline implant experience a rupture, it will deflate and the body will harmlessly absorb the saline. When a silicone implant ruptures, this can cause alterations in the shape of the breast and discomfort that may require surgery to address.

How often should I have my breast implants checked?

It's essential to schedule consistent consultations with a medical expert and adhere to the guidelines set by the FDA, which recommend undergoing ultrasound or MRI imaging for your breast implants five to six years post-implantation and continuing these exams every two to three years thereafter in order to keep track of the state of the implants.

What role does the surgeon play in achieving a natural look with breast implants?

In striving to attain a natural appearance with breast implants, the surgeon is instrumental in determining which type and size of implants are most appropriate. They meticulously perform the surgical procedure, customizing it to fit the patient's body structure and aesthetic ambitions.

From the initial consultation to the final follow-up exam, Dr. Horn and his staff provides compassionate treatment tailored to the specific needs and goals of each individual. Dr. Horn’s mastery and surgical skill in performing various face and body procedures, his dedication to patients’ safety, combined with his focus on unparalleled care and attention, make him one of the most sought-after surgeons in the Midwest. At his clinic, surgical options are paralleled by an array of non-invasive treatments and advanced technologies designed to help you rediscover your beauty potential.

60 E. Delaware Place, 15th Floor, Chicago, IL 60611

Receive texts for specials & discounts